Environmental Pressures
1.
Select only ONE of the following environmental
stresses: (a) heat, (b) high levels of solar radiation, (c) cold, or (d) high
altitude. Discuss specifically how this environmental stress negatively impacts
the survival of humans by disturbing homeostasis. (5 pts)
The human body
performs at it’s most efficient when the it is in a state of homeostasis where
a bodily function is occurring at the most desirable level. Thus, the human
body is actively attempting to stay at that level and is performing normal
corrections to its body systems to regulate itself back towards the desired
state. Therefore, once various environmental pressures are introduced to the body
it results in the body taking precautionary actions to try and maintain
homeostasis. These natural protective mechanisms can be circumvented when the
body is exposed to severe environmental pressures, such as when the body
overheats due to extremely warm climates or serious bodily infection. In such
cases, the body starts to slowly overheat as the core body temperature starts
rising from the normal 98.6 F range and eventually results in the onset of
hyperthermia around the temperature of 105-107 F as the body organs began to
shutdown from excessive heat exposure. The body attempts to cool itself by
sweating and reducing the core temperature, but these impacts are minimized in
situations in which there is high humidity in the air for the sweat produced by
the body cannot evaporate and cool the body. In dry, low humidity the body has
no issue producing sweat to initially cool itself but the excessive sweating in
a short timeframe results in the loss of water and vital salt nutrients that if
not replaced can lead to the dehydration of the body. The body also attempts to
adjust its salt concentration and urine volumes to account for prolonged heat
exposure.
2. Using
information in the assignment module, identify and explain four (4) ways in
which humans have adapted to this stress, choosing one specific adaptation from
each of the different types of adaptations listed above (short term,
facultative, developmental and cultural). Include images of the adaptations. (5
pts each/ 20 pts total)
Humans have adapted
to environmental stress resulting from excessive heat exposure through a
variety of different type of adaptations.
a.
Short term adaptation – The human body will start
to sweat when exposed to excessive heat to cool the body and lower its core
temperature back toward homeostasis. This involuntary body response alerts a
person that their body temperature has increased and that they will need to
find a way to cool themselves and replenish lost fluids.
b.
Facultative adaptation – The reddening of blood
vessel due to vasodilation that occurs a person to become flush when suffering
heat symptoms is an example of facultative adaptation. Heat is brought from
core areas to the body surface and is expressed in the flush appearance that
can be seen as people become acclimated to excessive heat
c.
Developmental adaptation – The Masai tribe in
Africa is an example of a developmental adaptation that developed in a
population over the course of generations in response to heat. The Masai are a
very tall and slender people that possess very long arms and their body
physique is perfectly suited to the warm temperatures that they live in. The slender
body type is effective in warm conditions because it assist in that the long
slender body has more surface area that is useful in the loss of body heat
d.
Cultural adaptation – People in excessive heat
utilize hats, light clothing, fans and air conditioning, sunscreen, hydrating
drinks and other cultural adaptations to help make themselves more comfortable
in these types of living situations
3. What are the
benefits of studying human variation from this perspective across environmental
clines? Can information from explorations like this be useful to help us in any
way? Offer one example of how this information can be used in a productive way.
(5 pts)
Studying human
variation in this manner provides a better perspective why there are so many
different variations of humans across the globe. This helps explain the
variability of humans for it helps demonstrate how certain traits are developed
to help people survive based on the environmental pressures that are unique to
their environment. Thus, in many cases these traits are an expression of
natural selection and provide humans with a greater opportunity to reproduce in
that environment and whether physiological or cultural they are passed on from
generation to generation to ensure the continued survival of a population.
These explorations are helpful for they provide insight into what type of
preparations need to be made to adjust to the environmental pressures of different
locations or climates that one may be faced with while travelling to different
sections of the world. For example, a light complexioned person travelling to
the deserts of Africa know that they must bring proper protection from the extreme
temperature in terms of protective clothing and sunscreen, since they recognize
their lack of melanin does not provide them with sufficient protection from UV
radiation.
4. How would you
use race to understand the variation of the adaptations you listed in #2?
Explain why the study of environmental influences on adaptations is a better
way to understand human variation than by the use of race. (10 pts)
In study of race in
relation to the heat adaptations mentioned above, one would look at the
variations in race as populations were exposed to various levels of excessive
heat exposure. By looking at race from this viewpoint one would understand the
influence of environmental pressures on how certain areas were populated, and in
terms of excess heat exposure there would most likely be a correlation between
the complexion of the people that reside in such an area. Therefore, the discussion
of the predominant group living in an area is not really a reflection of where a
race has settled, but rather an expression of a group of people whose traits
are most adaptable to thrive in a given environment. Hopefully, by examining in
this manner people are able to understand that looking at race is not a good
method at look at what differentiates people, but rather what we like to call
race is merely an expression of environmental adaptations that are intended to
help people thrive in their living situation. Thus, one expression is no better
than another for we are all just expressions of the environments that our
ancestors lived, so race is really nothing more complicated than that.




You do a good job of explaining the problems arising when the body temperatures rising. You then start to wander off a bit into discussions on how the body tries to fix this, but this is for the next sections on adaptations. You also raise the problem of dehydration, but this isn't caused by heat stress. This is caused by the body trying to *respond* to heat stress. The idea here was only trying to understand why heat stress itself was so serious a problem to homeostasis.
ReplyDeleteGood job on your short term and developmental adaptations.
For your facultative trait, is "flushiing" the adaptation or just a symptom of the adaptation? I don't doubt you understand this, but I want you to recognize that you left this open to question the way you presented it here.
Good cultural adaptation, but do people wear hats to keep cool or to protect themselves from solar radiation stress?
"These explorations are helpful for they provide insight into what type of preparations need to be made to adjust to the environmental pressures of different locations or climates that one may be faced with while travelling to different sections of the world. "
Since three of these four types of adaptations are biological/physiological/genetic in nature, we have no control over how we respond to stresses. Our bodies do this automatically, so understanding these adaptations actually doesn't help us much. Yes, we can use cultural adaptations to help us, but what about the benefits of understanding the biological traits? Can you identify a way this knowledge can be useful in a concrete way? Can knowledge on adaptations to hot climates have medical implications? Help us develop clothing that release heat more efficiently? Can we develop new means of home/building construction that might help decrease heat retention? How can we actually use this information in an applied fashion
Is that actually using race, or are you just using the adaptive response and layering race over top of it? Can you really use race to explain human variation? Understand that it is perfectly acceptable to answer this question with a "no".
To answer this question, you first need to explore what race actually is. Race is not based in biology but is a social construct, based in beliefs and preconceptions, and used only to categorize humans into groups based upon external physical features, much like organizing a box of crayons by color. Race does not *cause* adaptations like environmental stress do, and without that causal relationship, you can't use race to explain adaptations. Race has no explanatory value over human variation.
Firstly I really like how you divided your work into sections and it helped me go through and see every section clearly. This was a very interesting blog post. I never thought about how the body reacts to cold with sweats. This is an interesting adaptation and I am thinking back more and more to just how often that can happen. Seeing the developmental adaptations and how we have created advances like sunscreen is also interesting and useful information because we gather information and we are able to better create solutions to help us adapt. I wonder if this will have any sort of impact on evolution if we are solving all the problems we face with technology.
ReplyDelete